Topic: | Women Talking | |
Posted by: | Joe Conneely | |
Date/Time: | 18/02/23 13:40:00 |
I am possibly a bit too well versed in the effects of patriarchy in enclosed family religious communities when approaching this film, through the novels of Brady Udall and Netflix documentaries such as “Be good - Prey & Obey” and “Sins of our mother”. While they were about Mormons and their sub-sects, polygamy at least does not feature in this story of a Mid-West isolated religious farming community. Instead, continual sexual attacks and rapes of women (married and unmarried) has led to all the men departing for 24 hours to allow the women left behind to agree to forgive them. As is quickly established at the start of the film, the women use this rare freedom to instead review three options: to do nothing (forgive); stay and fight (for revenge or change); or, to leave the community (for exile). The film is apparently based on a true story though one suspects the film script does not follows all the book’s facts. The film avoids graphic violence simply showing the consequences in its different forms. Instead, it becomes an ongoing debate where an all women cast (only one male actor Ben Whishaw appears) go through all the options.The result is numerous monologues and coverage of all points of view, with a heavy religious tone pervading all the dialogue. While not doubting the film’s sincerity, after 90 minutes plus in a largely single set barn location plus a not unsurprising ending, I felt I had seen a cinematic sermon rather than an engaging movie. The film’s Oscar nomination feels more driven by a #MeToo context than the quality of it’s contents. |
Topic | Date Posted | Posted By |
Film Reviews 2023 | 01/01/23 20:16:00 | Susan Kelly |
Corsage | 01/01/23 20:17:00 | Susan Kelly |
Peter Von Kant | 02/01/23 17:18:00 | Susan Kelly |
If you must start so early…. | 02/01/23 18:36:00 | Sara Nathan |
Re:If you must start so early…. | 03/01/23 16:56:00 | Susan Kelly |
Re:Re:If you must start so early…. | 03/01/23 22:25:00 | Sara Nathan |
Re:A Man Called Otto | 07/01/23 12:46:00 | Joe Conneely |
Re:Re:A Man Called Otto | 26/01/23 16:59:00 | Susan Kelly |
Till | 08/01/23 16:36:00 | Joe Conneely |
Re:Till | 08/01/23 18:12:00 | Sara Nathan |
Re:Re:Till | 08/01/23 21:48:00 | Joe Conneely |
Re:Re:Re:Till | 08/01/23 22:26:00 | Sara Nathan |
The Menu | 13/01/23 18:53:00 | Joe Conneely |
Empire of Light | 15/01/23 16:58:00 | Susan Kelly |
Re:Tar | 20/01/23 20:13:00 | Joe Conneely |
Re:Re:Tar | 21/01/23 09:05:00 | Norman Redfern |
Re:Re:Tar | 31/01/23 18:54:00 | Susan Kelly |
Alice, Darling | 26/01/23 22:52:00 | Sara Nathan |
The Fabelmans | 29/01/23 17:08:00 | Susan Kelly |
Re:The Fabelmans | 29/01/23 18:04:00 | Joe Conneely |
Re: The Whale | 04/02/23 15:56:00 | Joe Conneely |
Re:Re: The Whale | 04/02/23 18:16:00 | Norman Redfern |
Re:Re: The Whale | 07/02/23 20:26:00 | Susan Kelly |
Knock at the Cabin | 04/02/23 17:26:00 | Susan Kelly |
All the Beauty & the Bloodshed | 10/02/23 21:51:00 | Joe Conneely |
Re:All the Beauty & the Bloodshed | 03/03/23 09:33:00 | Sara Nathan |
Blue Jean | 14/02/23 16:32:00 | Susan Kelly |
Re:Blue Jean | 15/02/23 07:54:00 | Sara Nathan |
Alice, darling | 15/02/23 07:57:00 | Sara Nathan |
Women Talking | 18/02/23 13:40:00 | Joe Conneely |
The Son | 18/02/23 16:35:00 | Susan Kelly |
Saint Omer | 19/02/23 15:11:00 | Joe Conneely |
Re:Saint Omer | 21/02/23 16:52:00 | Susan Kelly |
Re:Re:Saint Omer | 22/02/23 08:12:00 | Susan Kelly |
Broker | 26/02/23 15:11:00 | Susan Kelly |
Re:Broker | 01/03/23 20:33:00 | Joe Conneely |
Joyland | 28/02/23 17:33:00 | Susan Kelly |
Re:Joyland | 17/03/23 08:56:00 | Sara Nathan |
Close | 03/03/23 18:56:00 | Susan Kelly |
Alice, Darling | 05/03/23 13:38:00 | Susan Kelly |
Re:Alice, Darling | 05/03/23 22:08:00 | Sara Nathan |
Re:Re:Alice, Darling | 06/03/23 07:50:00 | Susan Kelly |
Re:Re:Re:Alice, Darling | 11/03/23 14:20:00 | Joe Conneely |
Re:Re:Re:Re:Alice, Darling | 11/03/23 19:32:00 | Susan Kelly |
What’s love got to do with it? | 05/03/23 22:22:00 | Sara Nathan |
Re:What’s love got to do with it? | 07/03/23 17:17:00 | Susan Kelly |
Rye Lane | 18/03/23 16:44:00 | Susan Kelly |
Re:Rye Lane | 19/03/23 09:54:00 | James Lewis |
Re:Re:Rye Lane | 20/03/23 22:04:00 | Sara Nathan |
Allelujah | 20/03/23 18:39:00 | Lorna Dodd |
Re:Allelujah | 21/03/23 08:22:00 | Susan Kelly |
Re:Re:Allelujah | 03/04/23 19:30:00 | Sara Nathan |
Lunana: a Yak in the classroom (subtitled from a language I’ve never heard of) | 26/03/23 18:03:00 | Sara Nathan |
The Beasts | 27/03/23 19:32:00 | Joe Conneely |
John Wick - Chapter 4 | 02/04/23 13:22:00 | Joe Conneely |
Re:The Beasts (Spanish and French with subtitles) | 03/04/23 23:04:00 | Sara Nathan |
Re:The Beasts | 04/04/23 15:34:00 | Susan Kelly |
God's Children | 03/04/23 15:56:00 | Susan Kelly |
Re:God's Children | 03/04/23 19:28:00 | Sara Nathan |
The Night of the 12th | 09/04/23 15:10:00 | Susan Kelly |
Re:The Night of the 12th | 19/04/23 19:36:00 | Joe Conneely |
Air | 11/04/23 06:52:00 | Sara Nathan |
One Fine Day (French with sub-titles) | 12/04/23 20:58:00 | Sara Nathan |
The Last Witness | 16/04/23 19:23:00 | Joe Conneely |
Re:The Last Witness | 17/04/23 07:25:00 | Susan Kelly |
One Fine Morning | 20/04/23 14:26:00 | Susan Kelly |
Cairo Conspiracy/Boy from Heaven (Arabic with subtitles) | 20/04/23 23:30:00 | Sara Nathan |
Re:Cairo Conspiracy/Boy from Heaven (Arabic with subtitles) | 27/04/23 15:33:00 | Susan Kelly |
The Three Musketeers: D'artagnan | 25/04/23 19:21:00 | Susan Kelly |
Re:The Three Musketeers: D'artagnan (French with sun-titles) | 25/04/23 20:33:00 | Sara Nathan |
Re:Re:The Three Musketeers: D'artagnan (French with sun-titles) | 26/04/23 08:06:00 | Norman Redfern |
Re:Re:The Three Musketeers: D'artagnan (French with sun-titles) | 26/04/23 10:19:00 | Susan Kelly |
Re:Re:Re:The Three Musketeers: D'artagnan (French with sun-titles) | 30/04/23 14:58:00 | Sara Nathan |
Re:Re:Re:Re:The Three Musketeers: D'artagnan (French with sun-titles) | 30/04/23 18:02:00 | Norman Redfern |
Polite Society | 28/04/23 16:28:00 | Susan Kelly |
Re:How to Blow Up a Pipeline | 29/04/23 12:20:00 | Joe Conneely |
Polite Society | 29/04/23 19:50:00 | Sara Nathan |
The Unlikely Pilgrimage of Harold Fry | 30/04/23 14:09:00 | Susan Kelly |
Coup '53 | 30/04/23 14:50:00 | Joe Conneely |
Vermeer: Exhibitions on Screen | 08/05/23 22:33:00 | Sara Nathan |
Re:Vermeer: Exhibitions on Screen | 09/05/23 07:21:00 | Susan Kelly |
Return to Seoul | 12/05/23 17:03:00 | Susan Kelly |
Re:Return to Seoul | 17/05/23 09:57:00 | Norman Redfern |
Re:Re:Return to Seoul | 17/05/23 21:39:00 | Joe Conneely |
Re:Re:Re:Return to Seoul | 22/12/23 23:17:00 | Sara Nathan |
The eight mountains (Italian with subtitles) | 13/05/23 23:38:00 | Sara Nathan |
Re:The eight mountains (Italian with subtitles) | 15/05/23 16:53:00 | Susan Kelly |
The Blue Caftan | 15/05/23 16:52:00 | Susan Kelly |
Re:The Blue Caftan (Arabic with sub-titles) | 21/05/23 07:18:00 | Sara Nathan |
Plan 75 | 16/05/23 16:00:00 | Susan Kelly |
Guardians of the Galaxy 3 | 18/05/23 09:39:00 | Mark Evans |
Re:Guardians of the Galaxy 3 | 18/05/23 17:40:00 | Rosco White |
Master Gardener | 01/06/23 15:49:00 | Joe Conneely |
Re:Master Gardener | 02/06/23 07:15:00 | Susan Kelly |
Chevalier | 13/06/23 18:01:00 | Susan Kelly |
Full Time | 20/06/23 14:54:00 | Susan Kelly |
No Hard Feelings | 22/06/23 14:29:00 | Susan Kelly |
Pretty Red Dress | 24/06/23 15:39:00 | Susan Kelly |
Asteroid City | 25/06/23 12:24:00 | Susan Kelly |
The Last Rider | 28/06/23 19:12:00 | Joe Conneely |
Re:Asteroid City | 03/07/23 13:01:00 | Adam Kimmel |
Re:Asteroid City | 01/08/23 20:35:00 | Sara Nathan |
Indiana Jones & the Dial of Destiny | 29/06/23 07:12:00 | Susan Kelly |
Mother and Son | 04/07/23 18:15:00 | Joe Conneely |
Name Me Lawand | 09/07/23 18:16:00 | Joe Conneely |
La Syndicaliste | 15/07/23 21:06:00 | Joe Conneely |
Oppenheimer | 22/07/23 18:52:00 | Joe Conneely |
Re:Oppenheimer | 23/07/23 15:34:00 | Susan Kelly |
Re:Re:Oppenheimer | 12/01/24 17:00:00 | Sara Nathan |
Barbie | 01/08/23 20:32:00 | Sara Nathan |
L'Immensita | 06/08/23 13:22:00 | Susan Kelly |
Afire | 20/08/23 13:45:00 | Susan Kelly |
Scrapper | 25/08/23 14:47:00 | Joe Conneely |
The Innocent | 26/08/23 19:57:00 | Joe Conneely |
Re:The Innocent | 30/08/23 20:32:00 | Susan Kelly |
Re:Scrapper | 27/08/23 14:35:00 | Susan Kelly |
Re:Scrapper | 23/12/23 16:35:00 | Sara Nathan |
Past Lives | 03/09/23 13:14:00 | Susan Kelly |
Re:Past Lives | 07/09/23 14:29:00 | Joe Conneely |
Re:Re:Past Lives | 08/09/23 09:57:00 | Susan Kelly |
Re:Re:Re:Past Lives | 10/10/23 14:58:00 | Alastair Banton |
Re:Re:Re:Re:Past Lives | 03/12/23 23:18:00 | Sara Nathan |
Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Past Lives | 22/12/23 07:15:00 | Alastair Banton |
Re:Past Lives | 16/01/24 10:06:00 | Adam Kimmel |
Passages | 05/09/23 15:27:00 | Susan Kelly |
Re:Passages | 06/01/24 22:40:00 | Sara Nathan |
Theater Camp | 10/09/23 11:39:00 | Norman Redfern |
Re:Theater Camp | 11/11/23 10:34:00 | Sara Nathan |
A Haunting in Venice | 17/09/23 15:32:00 | Susan Kelly |
The Lesson | 26/09/23 17:58:00 | Susan Kelly |
The Old Oak | 30/09/23 12:29:00 | Joe Conneely |
Re:The Old Oak | 03/10/23 19:39:00 | Susan Kelly |
Re:Re:The Old Oak | 25/12/23 22:58:00 | Sara Nathan |
Re:The Lesson | 16/11/23 23:50:00 | Sara Nathan |
Housekeeping for beginners (Macedonian/Roma with subtitles) | 08/10/23 09:35:00 | Sara Nathan |
Fallen Leaves (Finnish with sub-titles) | 08/10/23 12:31:00 | Sara Nathan |
Re:Fallen Leaves (Finnish with sub-titles) | 08/10/23 15:33:00 | Susan Kelly |
Re:Re:Fallen Leaves (Finnish with sub-titles) | 08/10/23 20:28:00 | Sara Nathan |
The Creator | 10/10/23 15:08:00 | Susan Kelly |
Priscilla | 11/10/23 08:17:00 | Sara Nathan |
The Great Escaper | 11/10/23 15:50:00 | Susan Kelly |
Re:The Great Escaper | 14/12/23 16:40:00 | Keith Iddon |
Re:The Great Escaper | 24/12/23 22:16:00 | Sara Nathan |
One Life | 13/10/23 22:19:00 | Sara Nathan |
Killers of the Flower Moon | 21/10/23 13:20:00 | Joe Conneely |
The Pigeon Tunnel | 22/10/23 17:55:00 | Joe Conneely |
Maestro | 26/10/23 17:46:00 | Sara Nathan |
Re:Maestro | 02/12/23 17:48:00 | Susan Kelly |
The taste of Things (French with subtitles) | 26/10/23 17:53:00 | Sara Nathan |
Are you there, God? It’s me, Margaret | 26/10/23 22:55:00 | Sara Nathan |
All of us Strangers | 26/10/23 23:02:00 | Sara Nathan |
American Fiction | 29/10/23 18:15:00 | Sara Nathan |
Saltburn | 30/10/23 21:53:00 | Sara Nathan |
Re:Saltburn | 12/11/23 14:47:00 | Susan Kelly |
Re:Re:Saltburn | 30/11/23 13:37:00 | Joe Conneely |
The teachers’ lounge (German with subtitles | 04/11/23 14:30:00 | Sara Nathan |
Earth Mama | 04/11/23 14:33:00 | Sara Nathan |
Fingernails | 05/11/23 21:46:00 | Sara Nathan |
How to have Sex | 07/11/23 21:48:00 | Sara Nathan |
Re:How to have Sex | 08/11/23 17:06:00 | Susan Kelly |
May December | 07/11/23 21:59:00 | Sara Nathan |
Re:May December | 24/11/23 13:55:00 | Susan Kelly |
Re:May December | 10/12/23 17:44:00 | Susan Kelly |
Anatomy of a Fall | 10/11/23 17:31:00 | Susan Kelly |
Re:Anatomy of a Fall (English and French - partly subtitles) | 14/11/23 22:02:00 | Sara Nathan |
Re:Re:Anatomy of a Fall (English and French - partly subtitles) | 15/11/23 08:36:00 | Susan Kelly |
Re:Re:Re:Anatomy of a Fall (English and French - partly subtitles) | 09/12/23 17:31:00 | Joe Conneely |
Re:Re:Anatomy of a Fall (English and French - partly subtitles) | 16/01/24 09:33:00 | Adam Kimmel |
The Zone of Interest (German/ a little Polish with sun-titles) | 12/11/23 18:12:00 | Sara Nathan |
The Killer | 12/11/23 20:04:00 | Susan Kelly |
Re:The Killer | 09/12/23 17:13:00 | Joe Conneely |
Dance First | 14/11/23 16:35:00 | Susan Kelly |
Dream Scenario | 15/11/23 19:38:00 | Susan Kelly |
Poor Things | 25/11/23 00:18:00 | Sara Nathan |
Rudy | 25/11/23 00:24:00 | Sara Nathan |
Napoleon | 26/11/23 15:03:00 | Susan Kelly |
Re:Napoleon. PS | 26/11/23 17:29:00 | Susan Kelly |
Re:Re:Napoleon. PS | 09/12/23 17:47:00 | Joe Conneely |
Dumb Money | 30/11/23 00:06:00 | Sara Nathan |
The Holdovers | 02/12/23 17:55:00 | Sara Nathan |
Re:The Holdovers | 02/12/23 19:15:00 | Norman Redfern |
The Peasants (Polish with subtitles) | 09/12/23 00:28:00 | Sara Nathan |
Wish. | 10/12/23 19:10:00 | Sara Nathan |
Re:Wish. | 11/12/23 09:41:00 | Lorna Dodd |
Killers of the Flower Moon. | 12/12/23 00:25:00 | Sara Nathan |
Re:Killers of the Flower Moon. | 13/12/23 09:16:00 | Joe Conneely |
Shoshana (mostly English but Hebrew/Russian/Arabic with subtitles) | 13/12/23 00:22:00 | Sara Nathan |
The Three Musketeers: Milady | 15/12/23 19:23:00 | Susan Kelly |
Fallen Leaves | 15/12/23 22:29:00 | Joe Conneely |
Re:Fallen Leaves | 19/12/23 16:03:00 | Susan Kelly |
Re:Re:Fallen Leaves | 19/12/23 23:30:00 | Sara Nathan |
Re:Re:Re:Fallen Leaves | 20/12/23 12:09:00 | Joe Conneely |
Re:Re:Re:Fallen Leaves | 20/12/23 16:22:00 | Susan Kelly |
Re:Re:Re:Re:Fallen Leaves | 20/12/23 16:23:00 | Susan Kelly |
Perfect Days (Japanese with sub-titles) | 19/12/23 23:39:00 | Sara Nathan |
Memory | 19/12/23 23:51:00 | Sara Nathan |
NYAD | 22/12/23 23:22:00 | Sara Nathan |
Wonka | 22/12/23 23:28:00 | Sara Nathan |
Little English (Punjabi/English with subtitles) | 23/12/23 19:28:00 | Sara Nathan |
Femme | 24/12/23 17:18:00 | Sara Nathan |
Flora and son | 25/12/23 23:03:00 | Sara Nathan |
Eileen | 26/12/23 17:59:00 | Sara Nathan |
Mother and son (French with sub-titles) | 26/12/23 18:04:00 | Sara Nathan |
Io Capitano (bit of everything and subtitles) | 26/12/23 22:03:00 | Sara Nathan |
Leaving to Remain (Czech and English with subtitles) | 27/12/23 17:55:00 | Sara Nathan |
Golda (mostly English but some Hebrew with subtitles) | 27/12/23 22:53:00 | Sara Nathan |
Pretty Red Dress | 27/12/23 22:58:00 | Sara Nathan |
The Promised Land (Danish with subtitles) | 28/12/23 23:06:00 | Sara Nathan |
The Royal Hotel | 29/12/23 22:33:00 | Sara Nathan |
20 Days in Mariupol (English narrative but all voices Ukrainian with subtitles) | 07/01/24 16:29:00 | Sara Nathan |
The boy and the heron (Japanese with subtitles) | 07/01/24 20:15:00 | Sara Nathan |
Society of the Snow (Spanish with sub-titles) | 07/01/24 20:18:00 | Sara Nathan |